Latest Posts

June 19, 2011

Book Review - Don't Ask Any Old Bloke For Directions

I remember reading about P G Tenzing (Palden Gyatso Tenzing), when he resigned from the Indian Administrative Service (IAS) and set out on an Enfield Thunderbird motorbike for his homeland, Sikkim. The news attracted attention because this was something that we do not associate with bureaucrats of the IAS. Some three years later, I read that Tenzing had passed away after battling cancer. I did not know at that time what he did in between. In the book, DON'T ASK ANY OLD BLOKE FOR DIRECTIONS - A BIKER'S WHIMSICAL JOURNEY ACROSS INDIA, he describes his journey around the country. The book is about his perception of the country and its people as he motors along. To his credit, he does not mention much about the system he has left, I am sure there must have been many juicy bits he could have narrated from his past as a bureaucrat. Nevertheless, the book brings out many aspects of this country and its way of life. His style of narration is not dragging considering the topic he is dealing with. He exhibits remarkable witticism and frankness, all of which makes the book an interesting read.

There have been many motorcycle books, not books about motorcycles, but books where motorcycles have been a constant part of the environment, almost a character. This book is not a philosophical discourse like "Zen and the art of motorcycle maintenance" or a story of self discovery and transformation like "The motorcycle diaries". As Robert Pirzig says in his Zen - in a car you are in a compartment, a passive observer watching the surroundings as though through TV. But on a motorcycle, the frame is gone and you are part of the scene, not just watching it anymore. In the journey that he describes, Tenzing plays the role of an observer and reporter, becoming part of the scene, absorbing his surroundings but not generally reacting to it. He is not trying to change the world; been there, done that in the IAS.

Tenzing wanted to travel at random, his whimsical journey across India. When you do not have a destination, what you have is only the journey or the present. You have a lot of time for yourself and to think. You may have some targets, but they are not destinations. Tenzing wanted to watch his hair grow, watch sunrise and sunset from sea level and from the heights of the Himalayas and to get his face burnt and toes wet. Simple enough targets that you do not continuously worry about. He had had enough of targets, had spent a life "groping around areas I didn't know or care about". It is one thing to realize that you are no longer enjoying your field of work, but quite another to break free. He signed his voluntary retirement from IAS on 15 August, the independence day and started his journey.  Motorcycles have been a symbol of freedom, and for Tenzing it became a tool for channelling his new found freedom. He went on to cover the length and breadth of India - "25320 kilometres in nine months with some stops in between or I would have died".

He says that he started the journey without much experience or preparation. He did not even know how to change a punctured tyre. He was used to travelling in chauffer driven cars and staying in government guest houses. But once he starts, he is served well by his large network of friends providing him with food, drink and bed at the end of long legs of journey back and forth across the subcontinent. He also learns the way of the road soon - staying in hotels outside city limits, eating from dhabas, getting drunk while he can and when he is not riding, dealing with the policemen on the road and trusting the roadside mechanics to do odd jobs on his bike many of whom refused to take money from him out of love for the Enfield he was on and liking the idea of an all-india ride he was doing.

Tenzing is from Sikkim, a state merged into India. He has experienced the lack of understanding that the rest of India has for its people and the entire north-east. He wonders that with his background, many expect that he needs to be constantly reminded of his loyalty to India. This country is divided into majority and minority - politically, religiously, regionally and along many other fault lines. It is a wonder how we have managed to stay together for such a long time. Maybe some of that credit should go to the IAS. I cannot think of giving that credit to the politicians because they have learnt to excel in creating new fault lines and exploiting them to their advantage.

Given the flow of his narration, I thought that the end was a bit abrupt. People run out of steam and time. What is important is to enjoy while it lasts. The book was a good read while it lasted.

Book Name: DON'T ASK ANY OLD BLOKE FOR DIRECTIONS - A BIKER'S WHIMSICAL JOURNEY ACROSS INDIA
Publisher: PENGUIN BOOKS
read more...

April 12, 2011

Sidney lumet - In memory


Last Saturday, the 9th April 2011, Sidney Lumet, one of the greatest of all American Film makers passed away. He was 86. In the year 2005, the Academy of Motion pictures gave Sidney Lumet a life time achievement award and three years later, he made his last and regarded by many as his most outstanding film – “Before the Devil knows you are dead”. His first film – “12 angry men” is also regarded as one of the best ever made… so, that should sum up a career, where he has made more great pictures than some directors have made just pictures itself. In 1996 he wrote a book called “making movies” any upcoming film maker, if need to chose one book for studying film, make it this one. Its just beautiful written and like his movies very precise and right to the point. It’s all about work.

I am a big fan of Sidney Lumet ever since I saw “The Verdict” and then have chosen to see lot of his movies.

I write this in tribute to a great film maker and about whom our own press didn’t give much space for. Infact, rediff movies and yahoo movies have not even mentioned anything. Any young film maker reading this, please take this man’s filmography as something to follow for life.

I would very much recommend few of them…

“12 angry men”, The Anderson Tapes, Network, dog Day afternoon, Child’s play, The Verdict, Serpico, before the devil knows you are dead…

There are two sites, where one can see a small interview of Sidney Lumet… probably his last… quite late in life, much after he made “before the devil knows you are dead”.


May his soul rest in peace…

Regards
Suraj
read more...

January 19, 2011

A Film Review...TRAFFIC


Directed by Rajesh Pillai
Written by Bobby and Sanjay

An accident occurs in a busy traffic signal at Ernakulum. A young man is critically wounded. At the hospital, the doctors proclaim that there is no chance for him to escape. At the same time, a 13 year old girl, is lying critically wounded at a hospital in Palghat. She needs a heart transplant. The question comes to the parent’s of the boy – shall we take his heart out while he is still alive to save the girl? The film does very well there to pose this dilemma and Saikumar as the boy’s father gives a heart warming performance. But then the director kills the plot by not showing us how and why the father finally gave in to the pressure. Over telephone the news comes across that he agreed. That change would have been nice, if I could see it. Ok.. the plot’s done and now we come to the major part of the movie – how do we transport this heart to Palghat from Ernakulum within 1 ½ hours? The stage is set for a thriller and from then on… the film falls flat. There is nothing thrilling and no hair rising moments to culminate. Each and every situation after that is so contrived to make the whole fascinating thrill look like a stroll in the park. At the end of the film, all you would want to ask – hey! What was the big deal?

I have some very serious questions to pose… I don’t know whom I am asking this and I don’t know who will answer it… yet…

• Why didn’t the heart be transported in an ambulance with an escort police vehicle?
• Why do we need someone like Sreenivasan to drive that Scorpio… just to make him a hero?
• When Joseprakash, a senior doctor and the chairman of Lakeshore hospital, tells the police commissioner that, if the police are not taking the responsibility, there are “chunakkutty (smart boys) ambulance drivers around” why only tell - why not use them?
• If there are ways inside Puthukad forest, or bylanes through which one can cover the distance between Ernakulam and palghat in 1 hour and 15 minutes, then why are we really complaining about bad roads and traffic congestions?

I feel the only thing we didn’t do in the travel here, is to stop the vehicle and sing a song… that was only thing left.

Now, in cinema you shouldn’t be asking logical questions… but I want to understand that this is serious cinema and there is life and death involved and if the rest of the crowd including police officers and doctors feel the whole thing logical then these questions need to be answered. Ofcoruse, also edach and every review that I read have heaped praise on the film… I am really disappointed to know that film criticism in Malayalam cinema is really lacking and that in turn makes for really lackluster cinema too.

The whole plot of Dr Abel and his sister and the problems from there on, is so much forced that we are asked to believe and empathize for characters. I thought may be the other way round, the heart coming for the boy would’ve made more interesting as we didn’t see anything of the girl to feel and empathize for her life. I felt for Saikumar, his wife and son… the only properly written characters.

As a film reviewer, one is not supposed to give away the plot points and story... but please don't mind this... there are no spoilers... everyone knows how its going to end... there is no suspense... you can watch it even after you read this. Its my point of view.

I was extremely disappointed with the film, because I heard quite a lot of good things about it and I wanted to see it, enjoy it… but I was really disappointed.
I can give it only a “Fair” rating - 2 Stars **

read more...

January 18, 2011

Makara Jyoti – “the divine light”


Every year, on the first day of the Malayalam calendar month of Makaram (capricon), the hills at Sabarimala and its premises are blessed with a view of a celestial golden light. In Tamilnadu and Andhra Pradesh, people still believe that God comes to earth then. According to legends there, that vision is supposed to cleanse all sins and everything else. Year after year, the crowd around the temple increases and the danger of a stampede or a bigger accident happening keeps looming large. This year an accident occurred… a stampede happened and yet in its aftermath, of all paper reports and comments, there is really no mention anywhere in any press or any news item for this whole act to be completely stopped.   

There are news reports of scams about everything… lot of news reporters and tv channels are hell bent on trying to expose wrong doings. Then, why can’t someone really stand up and stop this ‘government sponsored’ and ‘government run’ scam? Sabarimala is a tribal hillock… with all the money pouring in, the whole area has been transformed into a concrete jungle. A place filled with filth and terribly designed buildings. The money is not used to improve the facilities. I am not sure, that place can withstand this crowd for long. In the greed to make money, people are forgetting that there is an element of human beings involved. I will put down a small example...

I lived most of my student life at Vizag and near my house we had the dhobi, who used to also iron the clothes. His family consists of three children two girls and one boy. Every year he saves all the money that he is earning and makes the pilgrimage to see makarajyoti. He believes that if he is not true to his 41 day ritual, he will be eaten by tigers. All that money that he saves around the year, he comes and deposits at the temple, returns and continues work. He lives in a small hut, and for the all the 4 years that I knew him he has lived there. That is just a single story and likewise there would be many out there. Isn’t it time we stopped this cruelty? Every town in Kerala waits the coming of “ayyapas” from Tamilnadu and Andhra Pradesh so that this state can make money. From transport to lodging to food… tourism is not what gets Kerala its highest revenue but its from its own tribal god.

An accident was waiting to happen and by the look of it its only going to get worse… nobody is interested in the welfare of people… greed takes prominence. How can we make more money? After all the money we are making is long time ago, a simple tribal warlord called Ayyapan did  a brave thing in fighting the poachers and robbers who were looting the forests of Sabarimala and surroundings. That young tribal warlord is now seated as the second richest god in India, second only to Tirupathi. (a point to note is Sabarimala opens only for a total of approximately 160-170 days a year, compared to Tirupati which runs the whole year through).

In my personal opinion, its high time we stop this reality show.
In all the newspaper reports that I read, some people have suggested solutions - ‘to increase the time of the “jyoti” and to make it visible from more places…’
Oh my god! … Are we really living in a sane world?

read more...